A Dialogue on Magic, Miracles, and Modern Perspectives

Create a fictional dialogue between three individuals:
1) a practitioner of magic (like a priest or a witch or the like) from either ancient Babylon, Egypt, or Greece,
2) an early, first-century follower of Jesus or one of the apostles (like in the Book of Acts--but not Jesus himself), and
3) a modern news anchor (a real individual from CNN, Fox, NBC, CBS, NPR, or the like; pick someone you are familiar with).
Have the news anchor interview both the other two simultaneously on their show, just like we see and hear on our evening news shows. There should be debate and disagreement between the two guests on the show.
The practitioner of magic from Babylon/Egypt/Greece needs to be familiar with the views of their own culture (i.e., the readings we have done this semester) and to argue for the validity of the views on magic from that culture. 
The early follower of Jesus should take the position that we have researched in the past few weeks regarding the views toward miracles and magic espoused among many early Christians. 
Neither of the two guests on the show should sound stupid, but both should be eloquent and convincing spokespersons for their respective communities. 
The news anchor can and should be a bit antagonistic toward both, representing the common view in the West that magic and miracles are not reliable and that society now puts their faith in science.  For the sake of argument, we will pretend that the ancient guests understand something of the modern viewpoint but still reject it in favor of their own cultural perspective. (They are coming on a TV broadcast, after all.)
You don't need to quote the readings from this semester, just paraphrase them in your own words. No need for a bibliography or footnotes. But be careful not to plagiarize the readings from this semester. Use your own summary of them. If one of your ancient guests quotes an ancient authority (like Jesus or an ancient curse document), you may put that in quotations and have the ancient guest cite where it comes from. 
How long should this paper be? I would say 3 to 5 pages (single spaced). It's a short interview. Get to the main points we covered this semester: 
What is magic? How is magic different from science and religion? Is it different? Is magic a bad thing from, say, the Egyptian perspective? Are all miracles equal to magic? Was Jesus a magician? 

    A Dialogue on Magic, Miracles, and Modern Perspectives News Anchor: Good evening, and welcome to our special segment where we delve into the realms of magic, miracles, and modern perspectives. Tonight, we have two distinguished guests joining us - a practitioner of magic from ancient Babylon and an early follower of Jesus. Let's begin this intriguing dialogue. News Anchor: Let's start with our practitioner of magic from ancient Babylon. Can you share with us how you define magic and its significance in your culture? Practitioner of Magic (Babylon): In ancient Babylon, magic was deeply intertwined with religious practices and cultural beliefs. Magic was seen as a way to harness supernatural forces to influence events or individuals. It was not merely about tricks or illusions but a sacred art passed down through generations. News Anchor: Interesting perspective. Now, turning to our early follower of Jesus, how do you view miracles in relation to magic from the lens of early Christianity? Early Follower of Jesus: Miracles, as witnessed in the teachings of Jesus and the apostles, were manifestations of divine power rather than manipulations of supernatural forces. Miracles served as signs of God's presence and authority, aimed at demonstrating faith and spreading the message of salvation. News Anchor: It seems we have two contrasting views on the nature of supernatural phenomena. How do you respond to each other's perspectives on magic and miracles? Practitioner of Magic (Babylon): Our ancient practices of magic were deeply rooted in spiritual beliefs and rituals aimed at invoking deities for protection and guidance. While miracles in Christianity may exhibit similar displays of power, the intent and cultural context differ significantly. Early Follower of Jesus: Indeed, miracles in Christianity stem from faith in a singular divine entity, emphasizing a personal relationship with God rather than the manipulation of spiritual forces. The distinction lies in the source of authority and the underlying purpose of these supernatural occurrences. News Anchor: Fascinating insights from both guests. Now, let's address the modern perspective on magic and miracles. In today's society, science often takes precedence over supernatural explanations. How do you reconcile your ancient beliefs with modern advancements? Practitioner of Magic (Babylon): While modern science has provided valuable insights into the natural world, our ancient practices of magic were deeply embedded in cultural traditions and spiritual connections that transcend scientific explanations. Our belief in magic stems from a reverence for ancient wisdom and mystical experiences. Early Follower of Jesus: In the context of early Christianity, miracles served as affirmations of God's power and presence in the world, offering hope and faith to believers. While science may offer rational explanations for phenomena, miracles stand as testaments to divine intervention beyond human comprehension. News Anchor: Thank you both for sharing your perspectives on magic, miracles, and the intersection of ancient beliefs with modern outlooks. As we navigate the complexities of faith, spirituality, and science, it is evident that diverse viewpoints contribute to our understanding of the supernatural and the divine. Join us next time for more thought-provoking discussions on the intersection of tradition and modernity. In this fictional dialogue, we witnessed a thought-provoking exchange between a practitioner of magic from ancient Babylon, an early follower of Jesus, and a modern news anchor. Through their discussions on magic, miracles, and modern perspectives, diverse viewpoints emerged, shedding light on the complexities of belief systems and cultural interpretations across different time periods.    

Sample Answer