Choose 1 of the following ideas. Argue its feasibility, or lack thereof, and justify your reasoning. Use 200300 words to make your point.
Sedate airline passengers to prevent hijacking.
Solve the communications interoperability problem by requiring all responders to buy their radios from one manufacturing company.
Attach transponders to foreign visitors to prevent them from becoming illegal aliens and potentially forming sleeper terrorist cells.
The Idea: Attach Transponders to Foreign Visitors to Prevent Illegal Immigration and Terrorism
The proposal to attach transponders to foreign visitors as a measure to prevent illegal immigration and potential terrorist activities raises significant ethical, logistical, and privacy concerns, making it an unfeasible and impractical solution.
Lack of Feasibility:
1. Ethical Implications:
- Mandating foreign visitors to wear transponders raises serious ethical concerns regarding individual privacy and human rights. It infringes upon personal freedoms and violates the right to privacy, potentially leading to diplomatic tensions with other countries.
2. Logistical Challenges:
- Implementing a system to attach and monitor transponders on all foreign visitors would require a massive infrastructure and technological investment. The costs associated with such a system would be exorbitant and may not justify the perceived benefits.
3. Effectiveness and Discrimination:
- The assumption that attaching transponders would effectively prevent illegal immigration or terrorist activities is flawed. Criminal elements can find ways to circumvent such systems, rendering them ineffective. Moreover, targeting foreign visitors in this manner may lead to discrimination and stigmatization.
4. International Relations Impact:
- Enforcing such a policy could strain international relationships and create diplomatic tensions. It may lead to retaliation from other countries, affecting trade, tourism, and overall global cooperation.
Justification:
In conclusion, while the idea of attaching transponders to foreign visitors may stem from concerns about security and immigration control, its implementation poses insurmountable challenges. The ethical implications, logistical hurdles, effectiveness doubts, and potential diplomatic repercussions make this proposal unfeasible and incompatible with the values of personal freedom, privacy, and international cooperation. Alternative solutions that prioritize security without compromising fundamental rights and values should be explored to address the complex issues of illegal immigration and terrorism effectively.