Write an Argumentative essay on Visano concludes that ‘crime is a cultural product.’ What does he mean by this? Critically evaluate this position with reference to the role of media.
‘crime is a cultural product.’
In his book Crime and Culture: Refining the Traditions, Livy Visano argues that crime is a cultural product. This means that crime is not simply the result of individual pathology or social conditions, but is also shaped by the culture in which it occurs. Visano supports this argument by pointing to the fact that crime rates vary significantly from culture to culture, and that the definition of what constitutes a crime also varies from culture to culture.
For example, in some cultures, it is not considered a crime to steal food if you are hungry. In other cultures, it is not considered a crime to engage in prostitution. These differences in the definition of crime reflect the different cultural values of these societies.
Visano also argues that the media plays a role in shaping our understanding of crime. The media often portrays crime in a sensationalized way, which can lead to the public seeing crime as more prevalent than it actually is. The media also often focuses on the most violent and dramatic crimes, which can give the impression that all crime is this way.
This can have a number of negative consequences. For example, it can lead to people being afraid to go out at night, even though the risk of being a victim of crime is actually very low. It can also lead to people being prejudiced against certain groups of people, such as young people or people of color, who are often portrayed as being more likely to commit crimes than other groups.
However, Visano also argues that the media can be used to challenge our understanding of crime. For example, some media outlets have started to produce documentaries and news reports that focus on the root causes of crime, rather than just the sensationalized aspects. This can help to raise awareness of the social and economic factors that contribute to crime, and can lead to more effective crime prevention policies.
In conclusion, Visano's argument that crime is a cultural product is a complex one. There is no doubt that culture plays a role in shaping our understanding of crime, and that the media can also play a role in this. However, it is important to remember that crime is also a complex phenomenon, and that there are many other factors that contribute to it.
Critical Evaluation
Visano's argument that crime is a cultural product is a valuable one, as it helps us to understand the complex nature of crime. However, it is important to note that there are other factors that contribute to crime, such as individual pathology and social conditions. It is also important to note that the media does not always portray crime in a sensationalized way, and that there are some media outlets that are committed to reporting on the root causes of crime.
Overall, Visano's argument is a valuable one, but it is important to remember that it is not the only factor that contributes to crime. By understanding the complex nature of crime, we can develop more effective crime prevention policies.
Role of Media
The media plays a significant role in shaping our understanding of crime. The way that crime is portrayed in the media can have a major impact on how we perceive it, and on how we respond to it.
For example, the media often portrays crime in a sensationalized way, which can lead to the public seeing crime as more prevalent than it actually is. The media also often focuses on the most violent and dramatic crimes, which can give the impression that all crime is this way.
This can have a number of negative consequences. For example, it can lead to people being afraid to go out at night, even though the risk of being a victim of crime is actually very low. It can also lead to people being prejudiced against certain groups of people, such as young people or people of color, who are often portrayed as being more likely to commit crimes than other groups.
However, the media can also be used to challenge our understanding of crime. For example, some media outlets have started to produce documentaries and news reports that focus on the root causes of crime, rather than just the sensationalized aspects. This can help to raise awareness of the social and economic factors that contribute to crime, and can lead to more effective crime prevention policies.
In conclusion, the media plays a significant role in shaping our understanding of crime. The way that crime is portrayed in the media can have a major impact on how we perceive it, and on how we respond to it. It is important to be aware of the role that the media plays, and to critically evaluate the information that we are presented with.