Criminal Court System Presentation

Imagine that you have been asked to talk to a local high school history class about the history of the criminal court system. You will need to explain to the class how the American criminal court system came into existence, its evolution, and how it operates today.

Preparation
Review Weeks 1 and 2 readings from America's Courts and the Criminal Justice System.

Choose either your local federal court jurisdiction or your state court jurisdiction.

Assessment Deliverable
Create an 8- to 10-slide presentation to use as an aide as you speak to the local high school students. In your presentation:

Explain the history of the criminal court system and how it has evolved over time.
Explain the meaning of the dual court system.
Explain the history of jury trials and how they have evolved over time.
Explain the difference between a bench trial and jury trial and how each works within the system.
Explain your local court structure.
Explain how a jury works in your local jurisdiction.
Explain the history of the appellate court structure.
Explain the appellate court structure within your local state or federal district.

Full Answer Section

       
  • Federalist Papers:
    • Federalist No. 78: The role of the judiciary as the "least dangerous branch."

Slide 5: The Dual Court System

  • Federal Courts:
    • Jurisdiction over federal laws and constitutional issues.
    • Structure: District courts, circuit courts of appeal, and the Supreme Court.
  • State Courts:
    • Jurisdiction over state laws.
    • Structure: Trial courts, appellate courts, and state supreme courts.

Slide 6: The Evolution of Jury Trials

  • Historical Significance:
    • Trial by jury in medieval England.
    • The right to a jury trial in the U.S. Constitution.
  • Jury Selection:
    • Voir dire process.
    • Challenges for cause and peremptory challenges.

Slide 7: Bench Trials vs. Jury Trials

  • Bench Trials:
    • Judge as the sole fact-finder.
    • Faster and less expensive.
  • Jury Trials:
    • Jury as the fact-finder.
    • Ensures public participation in the justice system.

Slide 8: Your Local Court Structure

  • [State or Federal] Court System
  • Trial Courts:
    • Jurisdiction over various types of cases.
    • Role of judges and prosecutors.
  • Appellate Courts:
    • Review decisions of lower courts.
    • Panel of judges.

Slide 9: How Juries Work in Your Local Jurisdiction

  • Jury Selection Process:
    • Random selection from voter registration lists.
    • Questionnaire and voir dire.
  • Jury Deliberations:
    • Instructions from the judge.
    • Reaching a verdict.

Slide 10: The Appellate Court Structure

  • State Appellate Courts:
    • Intermediate appellate courts.
    • State supreme court.
  • Federal Appellate Courts:
    • Circuit courts of appeal.
    • Supreme Court.

Additional Tips for Your Presentation:

  • Use clear and concise language, avoiding legal jargon.
  • Use visuals (charts, diagrams, images) to enhance understanding.
  • Practice your presentation to ensure smooth delivery.
  • Engage the audience with questions and anecdotes.
  • Be prepared to answer questions from the students.

By following these guidelines and tailoring the presentation to your specific local court system, you can create an informative and engaging presentation for your high school audience.

Sample Answer

       

Presentation Outline: A Journey Through the American Criminal Court System

Slide 1: Title Slide

  • Title: A Journey Through the American Criminal Court System
  • Your Name
  • Date

Slide 2: Introduction

  • Hook: A captivating story or statistic about a famous criminal trial.
  • Thesis: The American criminal court system, a complex yet essential part of our society, has evolved over centuries to ensure justice and protect individual rights.

Slide 3: Early Roots of the Court System

  • English Common Law:
    • The foundation of the American legal system.
    • Concept of precedent and stare decisis.
  • Colonial Courts:
    • Early colonial courts and their limitations.
    • Influence of English legal traditions.

Slide 4: The Birth of the American Court System

  • Constitutional Framework:
    • The Constitution and its impact on the judiciary.
    • Article III: Establishing the Supreme Court