Surf the employment pages of 3 different corporate websites. Try to choose different industries and/or different-sized organizations for comparison. Analyze the major features, strengths, and weaknesses of the recruiting messages you view throughout each site, from the employment splashdown page to specific position postings.
Prepare a brief narrative report that summarizes, compares, and contrasts your findings.
• Does each organization rely on a particular style of recruiting message? If so, which one(s) and why?
• How well do these sites support the trends and strategies presented in this module's readings?
• Suppose you were an outside consultant brought in to overhaul recruiting at these organizations. What recommendations will you make to revise or change the site, or the message presented? Why?
Expect to take about 4-5 pages (double-spaced, 12-point font) to complete this assignment. Your work will be graded on content, clarity, creativity, correctness, and, above all, critical thinking per the HRA Written Assignment Rubric.
Full Answer Section
TechCo (Multinational Technology Company):
-
Major Features: TechCo's career page is highly sophisticated and visually appealing. It features a global navigation system, allowing candidates to easily search for jobs across different locations. The site emphasizes its innovative culture, employee development programs, and commitment to diversity and inclusion. It includes employee testimonials, videos showcasing the company's work environment, and detailed information about benefits and perks. Job postings are comprehensive, outlining responsibilities, qualifications, and company values. The application process is streamlined and user-friendly.
-
Strengths: TechCo's site effectively communicates its employer value proposition, highlighting its commitment to innovation, growth, and employee well-being. The global job search functionality is a significant strength, catering to a diverse talent pool. The rich media content provides a realistic preview of the company culture.
-
Weaknesses: While visually impressive, the sheer volume of information can be overwhelming for candidates. The emphasis on global opportunities might overshadow local or entry-level positions. The focus on "innovation" and "cutting-edge technology" might not resonate with all job seekers.
-
Recruiting Message Style: TechCo primarily uses an attraction-focused message, emphasizing its employer brand and the benefits of working for the company. There's also an element of aspiration-based messaging, suggesting that working at TechCo is a pathway to personal and professional fulfillment.
II. HealthCorp (Regional Healthcare Provider):
-
Major Features: HealthCorp's career page is functional and easy to navigate. It focuses on its mission of providing quality patient care and its commitment to community health. Job postings are clearly organized by department and specialty. The site highlights its competitive benefits package and opportunities for professional development. It also includes information about the organization's values and culture.
-
Strengths: HealthCorp effectively communicates its commitment to patient care and community service, which is likely to resonate with healthcare professionals. The clear organization of job postings makes it easy for candidates to find relevant opportunities.
-
Weaknesses: The site's design is somewhat dated and lacks the visual appeal of TechCo's page. The content is primarily text-based and could benefit from more engaging visuals and multimedia elements. The focus on traditional benefits might not appeal to younger generations of workers.
-
Recruiting Message Style: HealthCorp primarily uses a values-based message, emphasizing its mission and commitment to serving the community. There's also an element of stability-focused messaging, highlighting its long history and secure employment opportunities.
III. ManuCo (Small Manufacturing Business):
-
Major Features: ManuCo's career page is simple and straightforward. It includes a brief overview of the company and its products. Job postings are limited and often lack detailed descriptions. The application process is basic, often involving submitting a resume via email.
-
Strengths: The direct and uncomplicated approach might appeal to some job seekers who prefer a straightforward application process. The emphasis on family ownership and local roots could resonate with candidates seeking a close-knit work environment.
-
Weaknesses: The lack of detailed information about the company, its culture, and its open positions makes it difficult for candidates to assess whether it's a good fit. The limited job postings and basic application process could deter qualified candidates. The site doesn't effectively communicate the company's value proposition or its employee benefits.
-
Recruiting Message Style: ManuCo uses a practical-focused message, primarily focusing on the available job openings and the basic requirements. There's an implicit message of community-oriented employment, suggesting a family-like atmosphere.
II. Alignment with Current Trends and Strategies:
TechCo's recruitment strategy is the most aligned with current trends, incorporating elements of employer branding, candidate experience, and digital marketing. HealthCorp's approach is more traditional, focusing on its mission and benefits. ManuCo's strategy is the least aligned, lacking a strong online presence and a clear communication of its employer value proposition.
III. Recommendations for Improvement:
-
TechCo: While TechCo's site is generally strong, streamlining the information architecture and improving search functionality could enhance the candidate experience. Adding more localized content and highlighting entry-level opportunities could attract a wider range of talent.
-
HealthCorp: HealthCorp should invest in a website redesign to improve its visual appeal and incorporate more engaging multimedia content. Developing a stronger employer brand and highlighting its commitment to employee well-being and professional development could attract more qualified candidates. Exploring social media recruitment strategies could also expand its reach.
-
ManuCo: ManuCo needs a complete overhaul of its recruitment strategy. Investing in a professional website with detailed job postings, information about the company culture, and an online application system is essential. Developing a compelling employer value proposition and actively promoting it through social media and local partnerships could significantly improve its ability to attract talent. Emphasizing the benefits of working for a small, family-owned business (e.g., close-knit community, direct impact) could be a key differentiator.
Conclusion:
The three organizations analyzed in this report demonstrate the diverse approaches to recruitment in the digital age. While TechCo effectively leverages its online presence and employer brand to attract top talent, HealthCorp and ManuCo need to modernize their recruitment strategies to remain competitive. Investing in website improvements, developing a strong employer value proposition, and embracing digital marketing are crucial for organizations of all sizes to attract and engage qualified candidates in today's dynamic job market. A shift from simply posting jobs to actively marketing the employment opportunity and the company culture is essential for success.
Sample Answer
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Comparative Analysis of Corporate Employment Websites
This report analyzes the recruitment messaging and website features of three distinct organizations: a large multinational technology company (referred to as "TechCo"), a mid-sized regional healthcare provider ("HealthCorp"), and a small, family-owned manufacturing business ("ManuCo"). The analysis focuses on the effectiveness of their recruitment strategies, their alignment with current HR trends, and recommendations for improvement.