Is Doing the Wrong Thing Sometimes the Right Thing?

In Colleen Hoover’s novel Hopeless, the character Karen Davis finds herself faced with a moral dilemma. After rescuing her daughter from an abusive father, she makes the decision to lie about her true identity, pretending to be her daughter’s aunt rather than her mother. Although this act is undoubtedly illegal, it can be argued that Karen’s actions were morally justifiable. This raises the question: Is doing the wrong thing sometimes the right thing?

Thesis Statement

While it is generally accepted that one should adhere to the principles of honesty and legality, there are rare instances where doing the wrong thing can be morally justified. In the case of Karen Davis from Hopeless, her decision to lie about her identity was a necessary and responsible choice in order to protect her daughter from harm.

The Importance of Protecting Loved Ones

Karen Davis’ primary motivation for lying about her identity was to protect her daughter from the abuse she experienced at the hands of her father. As a parent, Karen’s duty is to ensure the safety and well-being of her child. By assuming the role of her daughter’s aunt, Karen not only shields her daughter from potential danger but also provides her with a stable and loving environment.

The Limitations of Legal Systems

While it is crucial to respect and abide by the law, it is important to acknowledge that legal systems are not infallible. In some cases, the law may fail to protect individuals from harm or deliver justice adequately. In such situations, individuals may be compelled to take matters into their own hands and make decisions that deviate from legal requirements but are morally justifiable.

The Consequences of Revealing the Truth

Had Karen chosen to reveal the truth about her identity, her daughter’s safety would have been jeopardized. Her abusive father could have used this information against them, potentially leading to further harm or even placing their lives at risk. By lying, Karen acted in the best interest of her daughter’s well-being, prioritizing her protection over the legality of her actions.

The Ethical Dilemma

Karen’s decision to lie about her identity creates a moral dilemma that challenges conventional notions of right and wrong. While honesty and legality are generally upheld as ethical values, there are instances where the greater good necessitates a deviation from these principles. In Karen’s case, the welfare of her daughter outweighs the importance of adhering strictly to societal expectations.

Conclusion

In the case of Karen Davis from Hopeless, her decision to lie about her identity can be seen as an example of doing the wrong thing for the right reasons. While it is important to respect the law and uphold ethical principles, there are rare situations where one must prioritize the safety and well-being of loved ones above all else. By assuming the role of her daughter’s aunt, Karen acted responsibly and selflessly, protecting her daughter from harm. This demonstrates that sometimes, doing the wrong thing can indeed be the right thing.

Sample Answer