View the below movies or TV shows:
Osborne, M & Stevenson, J. (2008) Kung Fu Panda. Paramount Pictures
Paper Content
A. After viewing the movie or TV show, select one of the supervisors (leaders).
B. Discuss THREE supervisory techniques, using specific examples from the movie or TV episode. Do not spend too much effort explaining the background or details of the scenario, get to the point of how they lead (or don't).
C. Make sure to discuss the following topics:
i. Which of the supervisory techniques were effective? Why?
ii. Which supervisory techniques were not effective? Why?
iii. Pick one scene and discuss what you would have done differently as a supervisor and why.
iv. How does a high-stress environment affect supervisory techniques, as compared or a less stressful environment?
v. What supervisory trait do you most relate to and why? You should include a personal account from your life.
vi. Why do supervisors fail if they are using a "textbook" technique? Explain using the scenes from the movie/show or your own personal life to enhance your explanation.
Kung Fu Panda: A Lesson in Supervisory Techniques
Introduction
Kung Fu Panda, directed by Mark Osborne and John Stevenson, is an animated film that tells the story of Po, a clumsy and overweight panda who dreams of becoming a kung fu master. Throughout the movie, Po encounters various supervisory figures who guide him in his journey towards self-discovery and achieving his goals. In this essay, we will explore three supervisory techniques portrayed in the movie, analyze their effectiveness, discuss a scene where I would have done things differently as a supervisor, examine the impact of high-stress environments on supervisory techniques, and finally, reflect on a supervisory trait that resonates with me personally.
Effective Supervisory Techniques
One of the effective supervisory techniques portrayed in Kung Fu Panda is leading by example. Master Shifu, the wise and experienced kung fu master, demonstrates this technique throughout the movie. He trains alongside his students, showing them the right way to perform various moves and skills. By actively participating in the training sessions, Master Shifu gains the respect and admiration of his students, leading to a stronger bond and enhanced learning experience.
Another effective supervisory technique in the movie is providing constructive feedback. In one scene, Master Shifu corrects Po's posture and technique during a training session. Instead of belittling Po or focusing on his mistakes, Master Shifu delivers feedback with empathy and patience. This approach allows Po to understand his weaknesses and work on improving them effectively.
Furthermore, setting clear expectations is also portrayed as an effective supervisory technique in the movie. Master Oogway, the wise old turtle, sets clear expectations for Po and believes in his potential to become the Dragon Warrior. By providing Po with a clear goal to work towards, Master Oogway motivates him to strive for excellence and pushes him beyond his limits.
Ineffective Supervisory Techniques
While there are effective supervisory techniques portrayed in Kung Fu Panda, there are also instances of ineffective techniques. One such technique is micromanagement. Tai Lung's former master, Master Shifu, initially tries to control every aspect of his students' training, leaving no room for creativity or independent thinking. This approach stifles the growth and development of the students, leading to frustration and resentment.
Another ineffective supervisory technique depicted in the movie is using fear as a motivator. Tai Lung's former master attempts to instill fear in his students to push them to excel. However, this fear-based approach only creates a toxic and hostile environment, inhibiting creativity and cooperation among the students.
Scene Analysis: A Different Approach
In one scene where Po struggles to master a particular kung fu move, I would have taken a different approach as a supervisor. Instead of focusing solely on correcting Po's technique, I would have acknowledged his effort and progress. By recognizing his determination and commitment, I would have boosted Po's self-confidence, enabling him to overcome his struggles more effectively. This positive reinforcement approach would have motivated Po to continue pushing himself while also cultivating a supportive learning environment.
The Impact of High-Stress Environments
In high-stress environments, supervisory techniques can be significantly affected. In Kung Fu Panda, when faced with the imminent threat of Tai Lung's return, Master Shifu becomes overwhelmed by stress. This leads him to abandon his usual effective supervisory techniques and resort to micromanagement and fear-based motivation. The high-stress environment clouds his judgment and impairs his ability to lead effectively.
Comparatively, in a less stressful environment, supervisors can employ more effective techniques such as leading by example, providing constructive feedback, and setting clear expectations. In these environments, supervisors have the mental clarity to focus on nurturing their team's growth and supporting their development.
Relating to a Supervisory Trait
One supervisory trait that resonates with me personally is empathy. I believe that understanding and connecting with others' emotions is crucial for effective leadership. In my own life, I've experienced instances where empathetic leadership has made a significant impact. As a supervisor in a previous job, I encountered an employee who was struggling with personal issues impacting their performance. Instead of reprimanding or criticizing them, I listened with empathy, offered support, and provided flexible work arrangements. This approach not only helped the employee overcome their challenges but also strengthened our professional relationship.
Failures of "Textbook" Techniques
Supervisors can fail even when using "textbook" techniques due to various reasons. One reason is the lack of adaptability to individual differences and unique circumstances. Kung Fu Panda showcases this when Master Shifu initially fails to recognize Po's potential because he does not fit the typical image of a kung fu warrior. By rigidly adhering to preconceived notions and textbook techniques, supervisors may overlook valuable talents or fail to address specific needs within their team.
Furthermore, supervisors can fail if they lack emotional intelligence. In the movie, Tai Lung's former master possesses impressive kung fu skills but fails as a leader due to his inability to understand and manage emotions effectively. Textbook techniques alone cannot compensate for the absence of emotional intelligence required to navigate complex human dynamics and build meaningful relationships with team members.
In conclusion,
Kung Fu Panda provides valuable insights into supervisory techniques through its portrayal of various characters' leadership styles. The movie highlights the importance of leading by example, providing constructive feedback, and setting clear expectations as effective supervisory techniques. Conversely, micromanagement and fear-based motivation are depicted as ineffective techniques. The impact of high-stress environments on supervisory techniques is also explored. Finally, personal experiences can help us relate to specific supervisory traits and understand why supervisors may fail even when employing "textbook" techniques. By analyzing these elements from the movie alongside real-life examples, we can gain valuable insights into effective leadership practices.