Original position thought experiment provides a powerful framework for guiding decision-making

Topic A: Rawlsian Justice
John Rawls claims that justice comes down to a notion of fairness. He proposed a thought experiment wherein he proffers an ideal "original position." The idea is that representatives of the people operate behind a "veil of ignorance" when determining what policies are in the best interests of all of the citizens. In brief, representatives are ignorant of their "The race, ethnicity, gender, age, income, wealth, natural endowments, comprehensive doctrine, etc. of any of the citizens in society, or to which generation in the history of the society these citizens belong" and "The political system of the society, its class structure, economic system, or level of economic development" (Wenar 4.6). They do understand different people have different life plans, that even if resources are scarce, "there is enough to go around," and have good common sense.
Discussion task: Imagine you are a representative behind this veil. Discuss and defend several measures you would take to ensure a fair and equitable redistribution of resources.
Wenar, Leif, "John Rawls", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Edited by Edward N. Zalta 9 January 2017. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rawls/

  Thesis Statement In the realm of Rawlsian justice, the concept of fairness is paramount, as exemplified by the original position thought experiment. Representatives operating behind the veil of ignorance are tasked with ensuring a just and equitable redistribution of resources within society. This essay will delve into the measures that could be taken by these representatives to uphold principles of fairness and justice in resource allocation. Measures for Fair and Equitable Redistribution of Resources As a representative operating behind the veil of ignorance in John Rawls' original position thought experiment, several crucial measures can be implemented to ensure a fair and equitable redistribution of resources within society. These measures are rooted in the core principles of justice and fairness that Rawls advocates for in his theory. 1. Prioritizing Basic Needs - Universal Access: Implementing policies that guarantee universal access to basic necessities such as healthcare, education, and shelter, irrespective of individual circumstances or backgrounds. - Resource Allocation: Ensuring that resources are allocated based on need rather than on arbitrary factors like wealth or social status. 2. Progressive Taxation - Redistribution of Wealth: Implementing a progressive tax system where the burden falls heaviest on those with higher incomes, thus redistributing wealth to support social programs that benefit all members of society. 3. Social Safety Nets - Ensuring Equality of Opportunity: Establishing robust social safety nets to provide support for individuals facing economic hardships or disadvantages, thereby ensuring equality of opportunity for all citizens. 4. Merit-Based Opportunities - Fair Hiring Practices: Promoting merit-based opportunities in education and employment to ensure that individuals are not disadvantaged based on factors beyond their control. 5. Investment in Public Goods - Infrastructure Development: Focusing on investments in public goods such as infrastructure, healthcare, and education that benefit society as a whole, rather than catering solely to the interests of a privileged few. 6. Environmental Sustainability - Long-Term Resource Management: Implementing policies that prioritize environmental sustainability and responsible resource management to ensure that future generations are not unfairly burdened by the actions of the present generation. 7. Community Engagement - Inclusive Decision-Making: Encouraging community engagement and inclusive decision-making processes to ensure that the voices of all members of society are heard and considered in matters concerning resource allocation. By embracing these measures, representatives behind the veil of ignorance can uphold Rawls' vision of a just and equitable society, where fairness prevails in the redistribution of resources. Through a commitment to principles of justice and equality, these representatives can shape policies that benefit the collective well-being of all individuals, regardless of their circumstances or background. In conclusion, the original position thought experiment provides a powerful framework for guiding decision-making that prioritizes fairness and justice in resource allocation. By implementing measures that prioritize basic needs, progressive taxation, social safety nets, merit-based opportunities, investment in public goods, environmental sustainability, and community engagement, representatives can navigate the complexities of resource redistribution with a focus on creating a more equitable society for all.    

Sample Answer