Every day, people utilize social cognition and perception to understand their world and others. Your task is to explore and critically analyze a video clip from a television show or movie that illustrates a concept related to social cognition or social perception found in chapter 2 or 3 of our textbook (e.g., schemas, self-fulfilling prophesy, availability heuristic, first impressions, attributions, etc.). The information from the video clip will be compared to information found in our textbook.
select only movie or television clips (not personally produced reels, TikToks, etc.). Do not choose a clip that may be offensive in terms of profanity, sexual innuendo, biased language, or unacceptable visuals. If you are not sure if your clip is acceptable, please choose a different clip.
- Select a video clip from a movie or television show that demonstrates a concept related to social cognition or social perception (see chapters 2 and 3 in our textbook).
- Analyze the clip in light of social psychology concepts (e.g., schemas, self-fulfilling prophesy, availability heuristic, first impressions, attributions, etc.).
- Your paper must include the following:
a. Title Page
b. First section: Briefly summarize the clip
c. Second section: Identification, description and analysis of the illustrated concept (e.g., schemas, self-fulfilling prophesy, availability heuristic, first impressions, attributions, etc.) with specific examples of how it is demonstrated in the clip (pretend that the reader knows nothing about social psychology and explain the phenomenon with citations from the textbook).
Full Answer Section
- Define and explain the concept in detail, using language from your textbook. Be sure to cite your textbook (e.g., "According to Aronson et al. (2022), schemas are...").
- Provide specific examples from the video clip that demonstrate how the chosen concept is at play. Don't just say it shows the concept; explain how it shows it.
- Critically analyze how the concept influences the characters' thoughts, feelings, or behaviors within the clip.
Example (continuing with "The Office" and schemas):
"The video clip from The Office brilliantly illustrates the concept of schemas in social cognition. According to [Author(s) and Year of Textbook, e.g., Aronson, Wilson, & Akert, 2022], schemas are mental structures people use to organize their knowledge about the social world. These mental frameworks influence the information people notice, think about, and remember. Schemas act as shortcuts, allowing individuals to process information efficiently by providing expectations about situations, roles, or groups of people. For instance, we might have a schema for what a library is like (quiet, books, librarians) or what a doctor's appointment entails (waiting room, examination, prescription).
In the 'Diversity Day' clip, Michael Scott explicitly attempts to activate and manipulate his employees' schemas related to racial and ethnic groups. By assigning cards with labels such as 'Jamaican,' 'Jewish,' or 'Asian' to his employees' foreheads, he forces others to engage their pre-existing schemas associated with these groups. For example, when Stanley Hudson, who has 'Black' written on his forehead, tries to speak, Kelly Kapoor (who has 'Indian' on hers) speaks in a caricatured accent, stating, 'I hate you, Stanley. You are mean to me.' This interaction demonstrates how Kelly is relying on a harmful stereotype schema associated with the 'Black' label, rather than responding to Stanley as an individual. Similarly, Dwight Schrute, who has 'Asian' on his forehead, is subjected to assumptions about his intelligence and mathematical abilities by other employees who are operating under an 'Asian' schema. The discomfort and awkwardness in the room highlight how the employees, despite knowing their colleagues personally, are influenced by the explicit activation of these broad, often inaccurate, schemas about different groups. This scene serves as a stark example of how schemas, when based on stereotypes, can lead to biased perceptions and interactions, underscoring the power of these mental frameworks in shaping our understanding of others."
Potential Concepts from Chapters 2 & 3 to Consider:
- Schemas: Mental structures for organizing knowledge.
- Examples: Person schemas, role schemas, event schemas (scripts), stereotypes.
- Clip Idea: Someone making assumptions about a new person based on their appearance, job, or a prior experience.
- Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: The process by which people's expectations about another person eventually lead that person to behave in ways consistent with those expectations.
- Clip Idea: A teacher's low expectations for a student leading the student to perform poorly, or a manager's high expectations leading an employee to excel.
- Availability Heuristic: A mental shortcut whereby people base a judgment on the ease with which they can bring something to mind.
- Clip Idea: Characters making decisions or judgments based on recent, vivid, or easily recalled examples, even if those examples aren't representative. For instance, fearing flying more than driving after a publicized plane crash.
- Representativeness Heuristic: A mental shortcut whereby people classify something according to how similar it is to a typical case.
- Clip Idea: Judging someone's profession based on how much they "look like" a typical person in that profession (e.g., assuming someone in a lab coat is a scientist).
- Anchoring and Adjustment Heuristic: Using a starting point (anchor) and then adjusting insufficiently from it.
- Clip Idea: A negotiation scene where the first offer significantly influences the final price.
- First Impressions: The immediate judgments we make about people based on minimal information.
- Clip Idea: A character forming strong opinions about another character very quickly, and how those impressions affect subsequent interactions.
- Attributions (Internal vs. External): Explanations for why people behave the way they do.
- Internal Attribution: Explaining behavior due to personality, disposition, or traits.
- External Attribution: Explaining behavior due to the situation, environment, or luck.
- Clip Idea: A character trying to understand why someone acted in a particular way, and whether they attribute it to the person's character or the circumstances. For example, someone yelling, and another character wondering if they are an angry person (internal) or if something bad happened to them (external).
- Fundamental Attribution Error: The tendency to overestimate the extent to which people's behavior is due to internal, dispositional factors and to underestimate the role of situational factors.
- Clip Idea: A character judging another character's negative behavior as a personality flaw, without considering the situational pressures they might be facing.
- Perceptual Salience: The seeming importance of information that is the focus of people's attention.
- Clip Idea: How a character's attention is drawn to certain aspects of a situation or person, and how that focus influences their interpretation.
- Belief Perseverance: The tendency to stick to an initial belief even in the face of disconfirming evidence.
- Clip Idea: A character holding onto a faulty first impression or judgment about another person, despite new information that contradicts it.
Remember to choose a clip that clearly and demonstrably illustrates the concept you select. Good luck!
Sample Answer
Analyzing Social Cognition and Perception in Film
1. Title Page
(Your Name, Course Name, Instructor's Name, Date)
2. Brief Summary of the Clip
In this section, you will provide a concise overview of the chosen video clip. Imagine your reader has not seen the clip.
- Identify the movie or television show and the specific scene or characters involved.
- Describe the key actions and dialogue that occur in the clip. Focus on the events that are relevant to the social psychology concept you will be analyzing.
- Keep it brief and to the point, likely no more than one or two paragraphs.
Example (if you chose a clip from "The Office" illustrating schemas):
"The selected video clip is from the television show The Office, specifically the episode titled 'Diversity Day.' In this scene, the manager, Michael Scott, attempts to conduct a diversity training session. After an external consultant's presentation goes poorly, Michael takes over and initiates an activity where he assigns various racial and ethnic stereotypes written on index cards to his employees' foreheads. He then instructs them to treat each other according to the stereotype written on their forehead, even though they cannot see what their own card says. The clip focuses on the discomfort and confusion among the employees as they try to navigate this inappropriate exercise, particularly when interactions highlight preconceived notions about different groups."
3. Identification, Description, and Analysis of the Illustrated Concept
This is the core of your paper. Here, you will connect the events in the video clip to a specific social psychology concept from your textbook (Chapters 2 or 3). Remember to explain the concept as if the reader has no prior knowledge of social psychology and cite your textbook.
- Clearly state the social psychology concept you are analyzing (e.g., schemas, self-fulfilling prophecy, availability heuristic, first impressions, attributions, etc.).