The Complex Mother-Daughter Relationships in Toni Morrison's "Sula"

  The Complex Mother-Daughter Relationships in Toni Morrison's "Sula" In Toni Morrison's novel, "Sula," the contrasting relationships between Nel and her mother, Helene, and Sula and her mother, Hannah, serve to highlight the complex dynamics of mother-daughter relationships. While Nel and Helene's relationship is characterized by strict societal expectations and the suppression of individuality, Sula and Hannah's relationship is marked by freedom and a disregard for societal norms. These contrasting dynamics shed light on the significance of self-discovery, rebellion, and the pursuit of personal fulfillment within the context of mother-daughter relationships. Nel and Helene's relationship is deeply rooted in traditional values and societal expectations. Helene, as a product of a strict upbringing, raises Nel to conform to societal norms and expectations. Helene's focus on appearance, manners, and respectability is reflected in her attempts to mold Nel into a "good girl." This is evident when Helene insists that Nel always present herself in a neat and proper manner, as she believes it is crucial for Nel's social acceptance. The narrator describes Helene's influence on Nel's upbringing, stating that "Nel knew that her mother's personal cleanliness was beyond reproach and she guided her own life accordingly" (Morrison 33). In contrast, Sula and Hannah's relationship is characterized by a lack of conventional boundaries. Hannah, who is viewed as promiscuous by the community, challenges societal expectations and embraces her own desires. She encourages Sula to embrace her individuality and prioritize personal fulfillment over societal judgments. This can be seen when Hannah tells Sula, "You gonna be a woman no matter what else you do or say or think" (Morrison 82). Hannah's disregard for societal constraints allows Sula to explore her identity freely without the fear of judgment or societal restraints. The significance of these contrasting dynamics lies in the exploration of self-discovery and rebellion within the context of mother-daughter relationships. Nel's relationship with Helene restricts her from exploring her true desires and individuality. As a result, she becomes trapped in a life that conforms to societal expectations but lacks personal fulfillment. Despite achieving the outward appearance of success, Nel is left feeling empty and unfulfilled. This is evident when the narrator describes Nel's dissatisfaction with her life, stating that "There was something undependable in Nel herself which had driven her away from her husband and children" (Morrison 174). On the other hand, Sula's relationship with Hannah allows her to embrace her true self and prioritize personal fulfillment. Sula's rebellion against societal norms enables her to live an authentic life, free from the constraints of societal expectations. However, this freedom comes at a cost as it often leads to conflict with the community. Sula's defiance challenges the established order and disrupts the community's sense of morality. This is demonstrated when Sula is condemned by the community for her unconventional behavior and perceived lack of morality. In conclusion, the contrasting relationships between Nel and Helene, and Sula and Hannah in Toni Morrison's "Sula" highlight the complex dynamics of mother-daughter relationships. The suppression of individuality in Nel's relationship with Helene contrasts with the freedom and rebellion present in Sula's relationship with Hannah. These contrasting dynamics emphasize the significance of self-discovery, rebellion, and the pursuit of personal fulfillment within the context of mother-daughter relationships. Through these relationships, Morrison explores the consequences of conforming to societal expectations versus embracing one's true self.

Sample Answer