The difference between combinations and permutations

Describe the difference between combinations and permutations in your own words. When should you use one instead of the other?
Decide whether each selection described is a combination or permutation:
a) When shopping for a new truck, you research 8 different models online and select 3 to test drive.

b) A school board elects a president and vice-president from 12 members.

c) Nine fans at a soccer game are chosen to meet the team after the game.

d) The class of 120 seniors at Washington High select 2 class representatives.

e) A coach chooses a pitcher and 4 infielders from a roster of 25 players.

  1. A city council consists of 10 members. Four are Republicans, three are Democrats, and three are Independents. If a committee of three is to be selected, find the probability of selecting: (write your answer as a reduced fraction) SHOW YOUR WORK

All Republicans

All Democrats

Full Answer Section

         

When to Use Which:

  • Use Permutations when the order of selection is important. This often involves situations with rankings, specific roles, or arrangements.
  • Use Combinations when the order of selection is NOT important. This usually involves selecting a group or subset where the arrangement within the group doesn't matter.  

Now, let's analyze each selection:

a) Combination: You are selecting 3 truck models out of 8 to test drive. The order in which you test drive them doesn't change the group of trucks you're considering.

b) Permutation: Electing a president and vice-president from 12 members involves order because the roles are distinct. Sarah as president and John as vice-president is a different outcome than John as president and Sarah as vice-president.

c) Combination: Choosing 9 fans out of 9 to meet the team doesn't involve any specific order or ranking among the chosen fans.

d) Combination: Selecting 2 class representatives from 120 seniors is a combination because the order in which they are chosen doesn't define different roles; they are simply two representatives.

e) Permutation: Choosing a pitcher and 4 infielders involves order because the pitcher has a specific role distinct from the infielders. The selection of a particular player as pitcher versus as an infielder creates a different team composition.

  1. Let's calculate the probabilities:

    The total number of ways to select a committee of three from the 10 city council members is given by the combination formula: Where is the total number of items, and is the number of items to choose.  

    So, the total number of possible committees is: There are 120 possible committees of three.

    All Republicans: There are 4 Republicans. The number of ways to select a committee of three Republicans from the four is: The probability of selecting a committee of all Republicans is the number of ways to select all Republicans divided by the total number of possible committees: Simplifying the fraction by dividing both numerator and denominator by their greatest common divisor (4):

    All Democrats: There are 3 Democrats. The number of ways to select a committee of three Democrats from the three is: (Remember that ) The probability of selecting a committee of all Democrats is the number of ways to select all Democrats divided by the total number of possible committees:

    The probability of selecting all Republicans is . The probability of selecting all Democrats is .

 

Sample Answer

       

Permutations are like arranging things in a specific order. Imagine you have three trophies and you want to decide who gets first, second, and third place. The order matters! So, giving the gold to Alex, silver to Blake, and bronze to Casey is different from giving gold to Blake, silver to Alex, and bronze to Casey.

Combinations, on the other hand, are about choosing a group of things where the order doesn't matter. If you're picking three friends out of a group of five to go to the movies, it doesn't matter in which order you pick them – the same three friends are going.