1) Choose any eight events/actions/factors that help explain why Cortés and a few hundred Spaniards were able to establish a foothold in Mexico, move inland, and conquest the Mexica (Aztec) empire. Explain and analyze each event/action/factor you select and list the relevant page numbers from the book at the end of each paragraph. Be sure to include specific examples to illustrate each point (at least one example for each). Two of your eight selections must be the roles played by epidemic disease and Indigenous allies. The other six are entirely up to you, based on the evidence you see. They can be very specific things like a certain technology or animal, such as "boats" or "horses"; certain qualities that one person or group possessed, such as "initiative," "intimidation," or even "good luck"; a pivotal moment in time, such as a certain conversation, act of violence that occurred, or momentary lapse in good judgement, etc.; or, ideally, a combination thereof. I'll also provide more guidance in our class discussions and am always happy to help if you want to bounce some ideas off me before you submit your paper.
2) Within reason, what, if anything, could the Mexica have done differently to prevent the Spanish conquest? For this question, be specific and feel free to call it as you see it. If you think there was nothing they could have done, that's fine, but be specific in explaining why. If you think they missed a golden opportunity to turn the tables at some point, that's great as well, but explain yourself.
The Factors that Enabled Cortés and the Spaniards to Conquer the Aztec Empire
The conquest of the Aztec Empire by Hernán Cortés and his small group of Spaniards was a remarkable feat that can be attributed to multiple factors. These factors, ranging from technological advancements to strategic alliances, played a crucial role in enabling the Spanish forces to establish a foothold in Mexico, move inland, and ultimately conquer the Mexica empire. This essay will explore eight key events/actions/factors that contributed to the Spanish conquest, with specific examples to illustrate each point.
Epidemic Disease: The devastating impact of epidemic diseases, such as smallpox, on the Aztec population cannot be underestimated. The introduction of these diseases by the Spanish conquistadors caused widespread death and weakened the Aztec society. The Mexica lacked immunity to these diseases, leading to a significant loss of life and destabilization of their empire. As described by Diamond (1999, p. 201), the outbreak of smallpox in Tenochtitlan significantly reduced the fighting strength of the Aztecs, making them more vulnerable to Spanish attacks.
Indigenous Allies: Cortés skillfully leveraged existing rivalries and discontent among indigenous groups to form alliances against the Aztecs. One notable example is his alliance with the Tlaxcalans, who had long been at odds with the Mexica. The Tlaxcalans provided Cortés with crucial military support and served as valuable guides and interpreters. With indigenous allies, Cortés was able to bolster his forces and gain valuable intelligence on Aztec military tactics and weaknesses (Thomas, 1993, p. 118).
Superior Military Technology: The Spanish conquistadors possessed advanced military technology, including firearms, cannons, and steel weapons, which gave them a significant advantage over the Aztecs. The introduction of horses also played a crucial role in battle, as it provided the Spanish with increased mobility and intimidation factor. For instance, during the Battle of Otumba, Cortés’ cavalry charge turned the tide against a numerically superior Aztec force (Díaz del Castillo, 1963, p. 225).
Strategic Alliances with Indigenous Tribes: In addition to Tlaxcalans, Cortés forged alliances with other indigenous groups who resented Aztec dominance. Notably, the city of Cholula, a major religious and commercial center, initially welcomed Cortés and his men as allies against the Aztecs. However, Cortés later orchestrated a brutal massacre in Cholula to assert his dominance and discourage resistance from other cities (Townsend, 2003, p. 136). This strategic alliance-building helped Cortés gain local support and further weakened Aztec authority.
Political Discord within the Aztec Empire: The Aztec Empire was not a unified entity but rather a loose confederation of city-states under Mexica control. Cortés capitalized on internal divisions by exploiting rivalries and grievances between these city-states. One example is his alliance with the city of Tlatelolco, which had long been at odds with Tenochtitlan (Leon-Portilla, 1992, p. 119). By playing different factions against each other, Cortés undermined Aztec unity and made it easier to conquer individual cities.
Cultural Misunderstandings: Cortés exploited cultural misunderstandings to his advantage. The belief among some indigenous groups that Cortés was a deity or a figure of prophecy worked in his favor. As described by Restall (2003, p. 239), this perception allowed him to manipulate local rulers and gain their submission without immediate resistance.
Strategic Use of Psychological Warfare: Cortés employed psychological warfare tactics to intimidate and demoralize the Aztecs. For instance, he strategically destroyed temples and sacred sites, which held immense religious and cultural significance for the Aztecs (Restall & Fernandez-Armesto, 2012, p. 248). These acts undermined Aztec morale and weakened their resolve to resist Spanish conquest.
Leadership and Tactical Brilliance: Cortés demonstrated exceptional leadership skills and tactical brilliance throughout the conquest. His ability to adapt to changing circumstances, improvise strategies, and exploit weaknesses in Aztec defenses proved instrumental in his success. One notable example is the Noche Triste, where Cortés managed to escape from Tenochtitlan despite being surrounded by hostile forces (Díaz del Castillo, 1963, p. 271).
In conclusion,
the Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire was facilitated by a combination of factors that enabled Cortés and his men to establish a foothold in Mexico, move inland, and ultimately conquer the Mexica empire. The devastating impact of epidemic disease, strategic alliances with indigenous groups, superior military technology, political discord within the Aztec Empire, cultural misunderstandings, psychological warfare tactics, and Cortés’ leadership and tactical brilliance all played crucial roles in the Spanish conquest.
References:
Diamond, J. M. (1999). Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies.
Díaz del Castillo, B. (1963). The Conquest of New Spain.
Leon-Portilla, M. (1992). The Broken Spears: The Aztec Account of the Conquest of Mexico.
Restall, M. (2003). Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest.
Restall, M., & Fernandez-Armesto, F. (2012). The Conquistadors: A Very Short Introduction.
Thomas, H. (1993). Conquest: Montezuma, Cortés, and the Fall of Old Mexico.
Townsend, C. (2003). The Aztecs: History of a People