The Formation and Contestation of American Identity

    The Formation and Contestation of American Identity Introduction The American identity is a complex and ever-evolving concept that has been shaped by various historical forces and events. This essay aims to explore the factors that have contributed to the formation of American identity, the ways in which it has been contested, and its inclusivity or exclusivity in defining who is considered American. Formation of American Identity Colonial experience: The early colonial experience, with its emphasis on self-governance and religious freedom, laid the foundation for American ideals of individual liberty, democratic participation, and religious tolerance. American Revolution: The American Revolution against British rule solidified a collective sense of American identity as colonists fought for independence, equality, and representative government. Westward expansion: The westward expansion of the United States throughout the 19th century played a significant role in shaping American identity. The frontier experience, with its emphasis on rugged individualism and manifest destiny, reinforced notions of American exceptionalism and the belief in the right to claim and settle new territories. Contestation of American Identity Slavery and Civil Rights Movement: Slavery and the subsequent struggle for civil rights have been key points of contestation in American identity. The institution of slavery contradicted the ideals of freedom and equality, leading to divisions and conflicts that persist to this day. The Civil Rights Movement challenged systemic racism and discrimination, contesting the notion of an inclusive American identity. Immigration and nativism: Throughout American history, waves of immigration have sparked debates about who is considered American. Nativist sentiments and discriminatory policies have sought to exclude certain groups, such as Chinese immigrants under the Chinese Exclusion Act or restrictionist policies targeting various nationalities. Cultural and religious diversity: The cultural and religious diversity within the United States has also been a source of contestation. Issues such as language, religion, and cultural practices have at times been used to create divisions and exclude those who are perceived as different or nonconforming to a narrow definition of American identity. Inclusivity or Exclusivity of American Identity Broad and inclusive aspects: American identity has often been broad and inclusive, embracing a diverse range of ethnicities, religions, and cultural backgrounds. The United States has been referred to as a “melting pot” where immigrants can assimilate into society while retaining their cultural heritage. Creation of “Others”: However, American identity has also been characterized by the creation of “Others” – individuals or groups deemed un-American or non-American based on factors such as race, ethnicity, religion, or political beliefs. This has led to marginalization, discrimination, and exclusion, particularly during periods of heightened xenophobia or political tensions. Analysis & Conclusion The formation of American identity has been influenced by historical forces such as colonial experience, the American Revolution, and westward expansion. However, this identity has also been contested through struggles against slavery, civil rights movements, debates over immigration, and tensions surrounding cultural and religious diversity. While American identity has often been broad and inclusive, embracing diverse backgrounds and experiences, it has also tended to create “Others” through exclusionary practices and discriminatory policies. This highlights the complexities inherent in defining a national identity that is both inclusive and exclusive. In the next assignment, I will defend the notion that American identity should strive for inclusivity by recognizing and valuing the contributions of diverse individuals and communities. By embracing a more inclusive definition of what it means to be American, we can work towards a society that respects and celebrates its rich diversity. In conclusion, the formation of American identity has been shaped by historical events and contestations. While it has encompassed ideals of freedom, equality, and democratic participation, it has also created divisions and excluded certain individuals or groups. Recognizing these complexities is crucial in fostering a more inclusive American identity that embraces diversity and promotes social cohesion. Works Cited: Foner, E. (2000). Who Owns History?: Rethinking the Past in a Changing World. Hill & Wang. Higham, J. (2011). Strangers in the Land: Patterns of American Nativism, 1860-1925. Rutgers University Press. Takaki, R. (1994). A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. Little, Brown and Company.    

Sample Answer