The Importance of Critical Thinking in Academic Briefs

This brief is “a short and concise written statement” The academic part of the brief means that there is a clear thesis statement and scholarly work that supports that statement.

  • Academic Briefs will serve as tools to ensue students achieve the highest possible benefit from the readings, lectures, and discussions.
  • These assignments help students focus on how to write a succinct thesis; a key skill required for future success.
  • More questions = more learning. Thoughtful and reflective questions about what we discuss and what we read is a goal of this course.
  • The briefs combine our exploration of theoretical phenomena and ideas from scholarly works, in-class discussion/activities, and current events.
  • Students have concise and condensed notes on the readings and discussions that provides them with excellent study materials for assignments and quizzes. 

How to do this Assignment?

  1. Use the Academic Brief Format provided below and the Assignment Evaluation Considerations in this syllabus to ensure the quality of the brief. Academic Briefs require clear thesis statements and scholarly support for thesis statements.
  2. To organize your Academic Brief cut and paste the Academic Brief Format provided below into your own word document and fill in the material required.
  3. Intro Videos 3-5 provide further detailed descriptions of the expectations and parameters for each part of the assignment. For example, Intro. Video 3 discusses Part 1 of the Academic Brief, Intro. Video 4 discusses Part 2 of the Academic Brief and Intro. Video 5 discusses in-depth Part 3 of the Academic Brief.
  4. The assignments are due via Brightspace at 11:55pm on the due date. The submission spaces will be entitled #1 Academic Brief, #2 Academic Brief.
  5. Your worst mark of the 3 Academic Briefs will be eliminated. This is an opportunity to get your best work recognized.
  6. Use any style of citation that you are comfortable with and ensure that it is consistent (For example, APA, MLA, or Chicago Style). Include footnotes or endnotes and a bibliography.

Academic Brief Format

Copy and paste, follow the instructions and fill it in the format below with your written work.  Each Academic Brief assignment requires that all the 3 parts described below submitted in one file on Brightspace. In other words, Part I, II and III of the assignment are all due at the same time in the same file with all the requirements listed in the format included below.

Part I- Discuss Insights from Lecture, Video Lecture or Discussion Session

  1. For this component, identify and discuss an issue discussed in lectures or discussion sessions that you have access to or have heard prior to the due date. For this section you can use any lecture or discussion session that you have access to or have heard prior to the due date.
  2. Once you have decided what lecture or discussion session you are going to use, identify and critically engage with one idea/concept/issue noted in that lecture or discussion session that attracted interest. In a scholarly manner explain why it is important. Anything we discuss that piques your interest can be used for this part of the assignment it all depends on the topics we discuss.
  3. Ensure you have a clear thesis and supporting arguments. Refer to the Assignment Evaluation Considerations section of this syllabus. It is important to critically engage with the ideas in a scholarly manner. You should have a thesis, prove your thesis, and include reference to one or two other scholarly works.

400 words for Part I

Part II Discuss Readings

  1. For the discuss the readings component of the Academic Brief write about an issue that you found interesting in the readings that precede the assignment due date or that on the same week of the assignment due date. For example, if the due date is on the 5th week of the class you can use material from the 5th, 4th, 3rd, 2nd, or 1st week of the class.
  2. Choose one of the readings, required or recommended. Using your own words, and in a critical and scholarly manner, identify and critically engage with one idea/concept/issue you found of interest in the reading.
  3. Ensure you have a clear thesis and supporting arguments. Refer to the Assignment Evaluations section of this syllabus. It is important to critically engage with the ideas in a scholarly manner. You should have a thesis, prove your thesis, and include reference to one or two other scholarly works.
  4. Create 2 questions that relate to the article and larger issues discussed in the class. These questions may be used for in-class discussion and debate. Do not answer the question, rather craft a compelling question that can be further discussed in class.

400 Words for Part II

Part III Connect Analysis of Current Events
Students will include all the part III requirements in their single Brightspace submission for the academic brief. Part I, II and III of the assignment are all due at the same time in the same file with all the requirements listed in the assignment. Students need only copy and paste urls for the discussion board component.

  1. Cite the url and title of one media item (article, podcast, or video clip) that relates to issues discussed during this class or in the readings. Only post the url on the Brightspace Discussion Board, do not post any commentary.
  2. Cite the url and title of a media time (article, podcast, or video clip) that you found interesting, posted by anyone else (from any class or even the prof.) on the class Discussion Board. Do not post any commentary on the class Discussion Board.
  3. In the Brightspace submission only, for this part of the academic brief students will write:

a. A 200-word commentary on the url/ media item you posted.
b. A 200-word commentary on a the url/ media item a classmate posted.

400 Words in Total for Part III

The Importance of Critical Thinking in Academic Briefs Part I - Insights from Lecture or Discussion Session One of the key insights that I gained from the lecture on critical thinking is the importance of questioning and critically engaging with ideas. Critical thinking involves examining information, ideas, and arguments in a thoughtful and reflective manner. It is not enough to simply accept what is presented to us; we must actively engage with it and evaluate its validity. One concept that particularly caught my attention during the lecture was the idea of confirmation bias. Confirmation bias refers to the tendency to seek out and interpret information in a way that confirms our preexisting beliefs or biases. This can hinder our ability to think critically and objectively. It is important to be aware of this bias and actively seek out alternative viewpoints and evidence that may challenge our own beliefs. Understanding confirmation bias is crucial because it helps us recognize our own cognitive limitations and biases, allowing us to approach information and arguments more objectively. By critically examining our own beliefs and seeking out diverse perspectives, we can overcome confirmation bias and make more informed and rational decisions. In order to support this thesis, I will reference the work of psychologist Daniel Kahneman, who has extensively studied cognitive biases, including confirmation bias. Kahneman's research provides empirical evidence for the existence and impact of confirmation bias on decision-making processes. Part II - Analysis of Readings In the assigned readings for this course, one idea that stood out to me was the concept of intellectual humility. Intellectual humility refers to recognizing the limits of our own knowledge and being open to new ideas and perspectives. It involves acknowledging that we may not have all the answers and being willing to revise our beliefs in light of new evidence or arguments. Intellectual humility is important because it fosters a growth mindset and a willingness to learn from others. It encourages us to engage in respectful dialogue and debate, rather than clinging to our own opinions without question. By cultivating intellectual humility, we can broaden our understanding of complex issues and make more well-informed decisions. To support this thesis, I will reference the work of philosopher Elizabeth Krumrei-Mancuso, who has written extensively on the concept of intellectual humility. Krumrei-Mancuso argues that intellectual humility is essential for engaging in productive and meaningful conversations, as it allows for open-mindedness and a willingness to consider alternative viewpoints. In addition to analyzing the readings, I have crafted two questions for further discussion: How can we cultivate intellectual humility in ourselves and others? What are the potential benefits of intellectual humility in academic and professional settings? Part III - Analysis of Current Events For my analysis of current events, I have chosen an article titled "The Importance of Critical Thinking in the Age of Misinformation." This article discusses how critical thinking skills are becoming increasingly crucial in today's digital age, where misinformation and fake news are rampant. It highlights the importance of questioning information sources, evaluating evidence, and engaging in fact-checking. In my commentary on this article, I will discuss how critical thinking skills can help individuals navigate the vast amount of information available online and make informed decisions. I will also explore potential strategies for teaching and promoting critical thinking skills in educational institutions and society at large. For my commentary on a classmate's chosen media item, I have selected an article titled "The Role of Intellectual Humility in Effective Leadership." This article explores how intellectual humility can enhance leadership effectiveness by fostering collaboration, innovation, and open-mindedness. I will provide my thoughts on how intellectual humility can contribute to effective leadership and share examples of leaders who embody this trait. Overall, this academic brief has allowed me to delve deeper into the concepts of critical thinking and intellectual humility. It has reinforced the importance of these skills in academic settings, as well as in broader societal contexts. By critically examining ideas, engaging with diverse perspectives, and staying intellectually humble, we can navigate complex issues more effectively and make well-informed decisions.  

Sample Answer