Eric Foner wrote, "the language with which World War II was fought helped to lay the foundation for postwar ideals of human rights that extend to all mankind." Do you agree with the statement as it pertains to African Americans? For African Americans, during World War II and the postwar era, what freedoms were extended or contracted?
"The language with which World War II was fought helped to lay the foundation for postwar ideals of human rights that extend to all mankind."
Freedoms Extended or Contracted for African Americans
The World War II and immediate postwar era (1941-1955) saw a fundamental expansion of economic and political opportunities, though the fight for full legal and social freedom was heavily contested.
Freedoms Extended (Expanded) 📈
The primary extensions of freedom were economic and military, laying the groundwork for the later legal civil rights victories.
Area of Freedom | Extension | Mechanism / Impact |
Economic | Access to Industrial Jobs (Freedom from Want) | Executive Order 8802 (1941): Issued by FDR under threat of the March on Washington Movement, this banned racial discrimination in the defense industry and created the Fair Employment Practices Committee (FEPC). This led to a massive migration of Black Americans out of the rural South to urban industrial centers, significantly closing the income gap between Black and White workers for a time. |
Military/Civilian Service | Opportunities and Desegregation | The demands of war led to Black men serving in combat roles (e.g., the Tuskegee Airmen) and increased opportunities within the segregated forces. Most critically, President Truman's Executive Order 9981 (1948) officially mandated desegregation of the armed forces, a major turning point for equal opportunity. |
Political Consciousness | Ideological Weaponry | The launch of the Double V Campaign (Victory over Fascism abroad, Victory over Racism at home) by the Pittsburgh Courier galvanized Black public opinion. Serving in the war strengthened Black soldiers’ self-conception as full citizens entitled to rights, fueling postwar political activism. |
Federal Policy Precedent | Government Accountability | Truman's 1946 Committee on Civil Rights produced the influential report, "To Secure These Rights" (1947), which called for an end to segregation and the establishment of permanent civil rights enforcement mechanisms. This placed civil rights on the national agenda for the first time since Reconstruction. |
Freedoms Contracted (Constrained or Contested) 📉
Despite the gains, the daily realities of segregation and white resistance often resulted in the contraction or severe limitation of existing freedoms, particularly in the South.
Area of Freedom | Contraction / Constraint | Manifestation |
Physical & Social | Enduring Segregation and Violence | Jim Crow laws remained legally enforced across the South, restricting freedom of movement, association, and equal access to public services (transport, schools, hospitals). Returning Black veterans, proud of their service, often faced increased hostility and violence upon return for daring to wear their uniforms in public or attempting to register to vote. |
Political | Voting Rights Suppression | While the Smith v. Allwright Supreme Court ruling in 1944 technically outlawed the "white primary," mechanisms like poll taxes, literacy tests, and outright intimidation (often backed by local police) continued to severely contract the right to vote for Black citizens in the South. |
Housing | Segregation via Policy | The postwar housing boom, driven by the GI Bill and federal loan programs, disproportionately benefited white veterans. Federal Housing Administration (FHA) policies promoted racial restrictive covenants and "redlining" of Black neighborhoods, contracting the freedom of Black families to acquire wealth through homeownership and access desirable, integrated communities. |
Sample Answer
I strongly agree with Eric Foner's statement as it pertains to African Americans. The ideological fight against Nazism's racial hierarchy and totalitarianism during World War II created a powerful moral contradiction for the United States, which was simultaneously enforcing a system of racial segregation and discrimination at home. This contradiction—the gap between American wartime rhetoric of "Four Freedoms" and global democracy and the domestic reality of Jim Crow—became the central engine of the postwar Civil Rights Movement.
The language of human rights, particularly the global focus on self-determination and equality in the newly formed United Nations, provided African American activists with a crucial international platform and moral leverage to critique US policy.