Critically appraise the therapy session and determine if the applicable principles are applied throughout the shown session.
Demonstrate your ability to evaluate your own reactions to the session.
Analyze how you feel this therapeutic modality may affect, enhance or apply to your future PMHNP practice.
Purpose:
IS NOT to evaluate the acting in the portrayals.
Is to demonstrate you can identify (include in your write-up) the principles of the applicable therapeutic modality.
Is to include how you felt the principles of the modality is or is not included in the therapeutic exchange.
Full Answer Section
- Behavioral Interventions: I would check for discussion of "homework" or behavioral experiments designed to test the client's negative beliefs in a real-world setting. For example, the therapist might encourage the client to try a new activity to see if their fear of failure is justified.
Evaluating the Application of Principles
I would then analyze how well these principles were integrated into the therapeutic exchange. I would determine if the principles were applied effectively, for instance, if the therapist's questioning was empathetic and collaborative, or if they were delivered in a way that felt confrontational or unhelpful to the client. I would note if the principles were
not applied, such as if the therapist focused solely on childhood trauma (more indicative of psychodynamic therapy) without linking it to the client's current thought patterns.
Evaluation of My Own Reactions to the Session
My ability to evaluate my own reactions is a critical component of professional practice. If I were a PMHNP observing this session, I would reflect on my emotional and clinical responses.
- Positive Reactions: I might feel a sense of professional satisfaction watching a therapist expertly use Socratic questioning to help a client gain insight. I might feel encouraged by the therapist's patience and validation, which are essential for building rapport.
- Negative Reactions: Conversely, I might feel a sense of frustration if the therapist failed to provide psychoeducation, leaving the client without a clear understanding of the "why" behind their distress. I might feel concern if the session seemed rushed, or if the therapist failed to adequately address a significant emotional reaction from the client. These reactions are not an evaluation of the actor but a professional self-assessment of what I would consider effective or ineffective clinical practice.
Applicability of the Therapeutic Modality to Future PMHNP Practice
As a future PMHNP, this therapeutic modality would significantly affect and enhance my practice.
- Enhanced Practice: The principles of CBT are highly relevant for the conditions I would commonly treat, such as anxiety, depression, and PTSD. By understanding and applying CBT, I can provide my clients with concrete, evidence-based tools to manage their symptoms. This approach complements medication management by addressing the cognitive and behavioral components of mental health disorders, leading to more comprehensive and sustainable outcomes.
- Direct Application: In a PMHNP role, I could apply these principles directly by incorporating brief CBT techniques into medication management appointments. For example, during a follow-up, I could use a quick CBT check-in to ask a client about their thoughts surrounding a medication side effect, helping them reframe their perspective and stay compliant with their treatment. I could also refer clients to therapists who specialize in this modality, confident that I have a strong understanding of their therapeutic goals. The modality's structured, goal-oriented nature would be a valuable asset in my practic
Sample Answer
Critical Appraisal of the Therapeutic Session
If a therapy session were provided, my first step would be to identify the
therapeutic modality being utilized. For this example, let's assume the modality is
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT).
Identifying and Evaluating Core Principles of CBT
I would look for the following key principles of CBT in the session's dialogue:
- Identification of Automatic Thoughts: I would look for instances where the therapist helps the client identify negative or distorted thought patterns that are influencing their feelings and behaviors. An effective application would involve the therapist asking questions like, "What was going through your mind just before you started to feel anxious?"
- Cognitive Restructuring: The session should demonstrate the therapist guiding the client to challenge the validity of their negative thoughts. I would look for the use of Socratic questioning to help the client examine the evidence for and against their beliefs, rather than simply telling them their thoughts are wrong.