US healthcare Delivery System

Evaluate the three aims of access, cost, and quality in the US healthcare system. (CLOs 4) (20 Points)

The United States' health care delivery system has a triad of aims related to access, cost, and quality of care. Evaluate the extent to which the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has achieved the primary aims of enabling its population--approximately 320 million people--to receive health services when needed, while simultaneously containing costs and assuring that health services meet standards of quality.

To prepare for this discussion, please reflect on the learning resources and the media below, as well as your personal and/or professional experiences you have had with health care delivery in the United States and answer the questions that follows:

US healthcare Delivery System - HTML
As you form your ideas, consider:
How has the provisions of ACA changed the U.S. health care delivery and access to care? Be specific about the provision(s) that you are discussing – explain the provision(s) and the effects.
In your discussion, address why is it that despite public and private health insurance programs, some U.S. residents are without health care coverage?
What are some of the effects of not having health insurance on personal and national levels.
Identify possible approaches to improve population health and address health inequities.

Full Answer Section

         
      • Pre-existing Condition Protections: The ACA prohibited insurers from denying coverage or charging higher premiums based on pre-existing conditions, improving access for those with chronic illnesses.
    • Effects: The ACA resulted in a substantial decrease in the uninsured rate. However, gaps remain.
  • Persistent Barriers:
    • Despite the ACA, some U.S. residents remain uninsured due to:
      • Medicaid Expansion Gaps: States that didn't expand Medicaid left many low-income individuals without affordable options.
      • Affordability Issues: Even with subsidies, insurance premiums and out-of-pocket costs can be prohibitively expensive for some.
      • Immigration Status: Undocumented immigrants are generally ineligible for ACA coverage.
      • Opting Out: Some individuals choose not to purchase insurance, even when it's available.

2. Cost:

  • ACA's Impact:
    • The ACA included provisions aimed at cost containment, such as:
      • Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs): These promote coordinated care to reduce unnecessary spending.
      • Preventive Care Coverage: The ACA mandated coverage for preventive services, aiming to reduce long-term healthcare costs.
      • Limits on Administrative Costs: The ACA placed limits on insurance companies' administrative costs.
    • Effects: The ACA's impact on cost containment has been mixed. Healthcare costs continue to rise, although some studies suggest the ACA slowed the rate of increase.
  • Cost Challenges:
    • The U.S. healthcare system faces inherent cost challenges, including:
      • High Administrative Costs: The fragmented nature of the system leads to high administrative overhead.
      • Drug Prices: Prescription drug prices are significantly higher in the U.S. than in other developed countries.
      • Fee-for-Service Model: The fee-for-service model incentivizes providers to perform more procedures, which can drive up costs.

3. Quality:

  • ACA's Impact:
    • The ACA emphasized quality improvement through:
      • Quality Measures: The ACA promoted the use of quality measures to assess and improve healthcare delivery.
      • Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI): PCORI funds research to improve the quality and effectiveness of healthcare.
      • Electronic Health Records (EHRs): The ACA encouraged the adoption of EHRs to improve care coordination and quality.
    • Effects: The ACA has contributed to improvements in some quality measures, such as preventive care and hospital readmission rates.
  • Quality Variations:
    • Significant quality variations exist across the U.S., influenced by factors such as:
      • Geographic Location: Rural areas often have limited access to specialized care.
      • Socioeconomic Status: Low-income individuals and minorities often experience disparities in quality of care.
      • Provider Performance: Variations in provider performance can lead to differences in patient outcomes.

Effects of Lack of Health Insurance:

  • Personal Level:
    • Increased risk of illness and death.
    • Financial hardship due to medical bills.
    • Delayed or forgone care.
    • Increased mental health issues.
  • National Level:
    • Higher healthcare costs due to emergency room use.
    • Decreased productivity due to illness.
    • Increased public health risks.

Improving Population Health and Addressing Inequities:

  • Expanding Medicaid: Full Medicaid expansion in all states.
  • Addressing Affordability: Implementing cost-containment measures and providing more generous subsidies.
  • Promoting Preventive Care: Investing in community-based prevention programs.
  • Addressing Social Determinants of Health: Addressing factors like poverty, housing, and education.
  • Improving Data Collection: collecting more accurate data on health disparities.
  • Promoting Telehealth: Expanding access to telehealth services, especially in rural areas.
  • Standardizing and simplifying the health care system.

By addressing these challenges, the U.S. can move closer to achieving its goals of accessible, affordable, and high-quality healthcare for all.

 

Sample Answer

       

Evaluating the U.S. healthcare system's aims of access, cost, and quality, particularly in light of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), reveals a complex picture. Here's a breakdown:

1. Access:

  • ACA's Impact:
    • The ACA significantly expanded access through provisions like:
      • Medicaid Expansion: This aimed to extend Medicaid eligibility to more low-income individuals. However, not all states participated, leading to a patchwork of coverage.
      • Health Insurance Marketplaces: These provided subsidized insurance options for individuals and families without employer-sponsored coverage.
      • Essential Health Benefits: The ACA mandated that insurance plans cover a set of essential health benefits, ensuring a baseline level of coverage.