Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that focuses on maximizing overall happiness

A dentist has asked his assistant to perform a cleaning on a patient. The assistant has observed many cleanings and she’s confident she can do a good job. But the assistant is not licensed to carry out a cleaning and she points this out to her boss. The dentist offers her $30 cash on the side and the assistant accepts the arrangement. The assistant performs the cleaning and the procedure goes smoothly. The patient has no idea what’s happened and is satisfied with the office visit. Fully explain and apply utilitarianism to this particular situation. Was it OK for the dentist and assistant to treat the patient this way? Describe how utilitarianism works in general and address factors that would be important according to this view. Do you think the dentist and assistant behaved morally? Justify your own view. Write 2-3 paragraphs.

Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that focuses on maximizing overall happiness or utility for the greatest number of people. According to this theory, an action is morally right if it leads to the greatest amount of happiness and minimizes suffering. In the given situation, the dentist and assistant's actions can be analyzed through the lens of utilitarianism. From a utilitarian perspective, the consequences of the dentist and assistant's actions should be considered. On one hand, the patient received a cleaning that went smoothly and left the office satisfied, indicating a positive outcome. The patient's dental health was taken care of, and their overall well-being was improved. On the other hand, the dentist and assistant engaged in unethical behavior by performing a procedure without the proper license and deceitfully accepting cash on the side. To determine whether their actions were morally acceptable, it is necessary to weigh the happiness and suffering caused by their actions. While the patient experienced immediate benefits from the cleaning, there is a potential for harm in the long run if complications arise due to improper treatment. Additionally, the dentist and assistant's actions undermine the trust between patients and healthcare professionals, which can have broader negative consequences for society. In my view, the dentist and assistant did not behave morally. Although their actions may have resulted in short-term happiness for the patient, they violated professional ethics and potentially put the patient's long-term well-being at risk. Moreover, their behavior undermines the integrity of the dental profession and erodes public trust. From a utilitarian standpoint, it is important to consider not only the immediate consequences but also the potential long-term impact of actions on overall happiness and well-being.  

Sample Answer